IXCHEL Mexican Cuisine
The Living Legacy of The Yucatán
Location
130 Old Town Rd
East Setauket, NY 11733
Attendance
73 Guests
Connect with the restaurant
Event Recap
Dead Chefs Society stepped out to Setauket and into the Yucatan in July courtesy of Ixchel Mexican Cuisine and its idyllic backyard, its wooded motif and shade sails evocative of a seaside resort in Tulum. Wedged between oppressive heat and smoky, orange skies, DCS had a “Summer Soiree” for the ages.
Ixchel came to play, under the direction of owners Juan and Daphnee Munar, chef-extraordinaire Amelia Sanchez, and the day-of operation of Roberto and Luisa, the tone was set as soon as we saw that massive TV with the DCS logo, which would play the first ever powerpoint prepared for us by a restaurant at an event. Clearly, we’ve hit the bigtime!
Set to soothing tunes of tropical house, our trip to the Yucatan brought us back hundreds of years to the Mayan period and threaded a line from those times through the ensuing Caribbean and Spanish influence inflected in regional cuisine. It is said that the cuisine of that region reflects more of an Island-influence than that of the rest of continental Mexico, and from the citrusy Aguachile Tulum to the native “boniato” in the Kanki Shrimp through the key lime twist of Carlota de Limon, DCS got a thorough taste of that notion. But it was, for many, the Yucatan staple Cochinata Pibil and, for my peso, the best mole I’ve had that especially stole the show.
Heads have quite literally once rolled for this cuisine in the past, but now it’s just our widening eyes and yearning stomachs making moves. We hope you’ll soon make a return trip to Ixchel, one of Long Island’s most unique Mexican dining experiences.
Dishing it with DCS
Mayan and Yucatán Cuisine tells a story of continuity and adaptation spanning thousands of years. At its ancient core were sacred staples like corn, beans, squash, chiles, pumpkin seeds, cacao, turkey, seafood, and honey. For the Maya, corn was more than food. According to the Popol Vuh, humanity itself was created from maize.Hallmarks of the cuisine include earthy achiote, bright citrus, fiery habanero, pumpkin seed sauces, and cooking in banana leaves or underground pib ovens. After Spanish colonization came transformative ingredients such as pork, citrus, dairy, garlic, and spices, which fused with indigenous traditions to create iconic dishes like Cochinita Pibil.Unlike many Mexican regions, Yucatán also absorbed strong Caribbean influences through trade. Modern Yucatecan cuisine remains vibrant and distinctive, balancing ancient techniques with colonial and tropical flavors. Few cuisines offer such a direct culinary thread from pre Columbian civilization to the present day.
Agua de Tamarindo is one of Mexico’s most beloved aguas frescas, a refreshing drink made from tamarind pulp, water, and sweetener. Its flavor is uniquely sweet, tart, fruity, and slightly earthy, often compared to lemonade mixed with dates or brown sugar. Originating in tropical Africa, it spread to India and the Arab world before Spanish traders brought it to the Americas in the 16th century. Though unknown to the ancient Maya, the drink over time became deeply embedded in modern Yucatán, where its cooling, sweet-sour profile makes it ideal for the peninsula’s hot climate.
Habanero/Habanero Salsa. Few condiments are more essential to the Yucatán Peninsula than this hot salsa, served alongside everything from cochinita pibil to panuchos and seafood. More than just heat, habaneros bring bright citrusy, fruity, almost floral notes that balance rich, earthy dishes. Ancient Maya used habanero in sauces, stews, drinks, and medicinal preparations, making the chili one of the strongest culinary links between ancient and modern Yucatán. Today, Yucatán is one of the world’s most important habanero-growing regions.
Sopa de Tortilla Yum Kaax is a modern, Mayan-inspired take on classic tortilla soup, layering a crunch, creaminess, acidity, and deep savory flavor.The name is especially meaningful: Yum Kaax was the Mayan god of maize, agriculture, and wild abundance.. For the Maya, maize was sacred. According to the Popol Vuh, humans were created from corn dough, making tortillas far more than food. They were central to identity and survival. The soup itself takes this ancient ingredient and ties it, via cheese and pork, to the Spanish era. The dish beautifully represents culinary fusion: sacred Mayan corn meeting colonial ingredients and modern Mexican comfort food. It offers a delicious bridge between ancient tradition and contemporary Yucatán.
Aguachile is a traditional Mexican seafood preparation where raw shrimp is dressed in lime, chiles, salt, and herbs. The name literally means “chile water.” Unlike ceviche, aguachile is served almost immediately, preserving the seafood’s delicate texture while delivering bright acidity and bold heat.“Aguachile Tulum” is a modern interpretation shaped by the culinary identity of Tulum, reflectingthe flavors of today’s Yucatán Peninsula through local seafood, habanero, citrus, avocado, coconut, and tropical fruits. Aguachile Tulum represents modern Mexico’s evolution: native roots transformed by Caribbean flavors, chef-driven creativity, and Yucatán’s vibrant tropical palate.
Sopecitos Prehispanicos are a modern tribute to indigenous Mesoamerican cuisine. Built on masa, or nixtamalized corn dough, these small thick corn rounds serve as edible platforms for toppings such as beans, pumpkin seed sauces, turkey, chaya, mushrooms, or roasted chiles. The Maya may not have made modern sopes exactly as we know them, but they absolutely worked with the sacred, to them, masa to create tortillas, tamales, and griddled corn cakes. What makes these “prehispanic” is the emphasis on indigenous ingredients and the absence of colonial additions like cheese, crema, pork, or beef.
Ensalada de Nopales is one of the most deeply Mesoamerican dishes you can serve, long a part of the pre Columbian diet. Made from cooked cactus paddles, nopal has a bright vegetal flavor often compared to green beans or asparagus, with a texture similar to okra. Nopales were prized for food, hydration, and medicine, especially in harsh climates, symbolizing resilience and survival. Used by the the Maya, cactus became less essential to Yucatán cuisine as time went on before gaining once more in popularity in central Mexico. Still, nopal reflects the same adaptability that defined Maya civilization.
Mole Bacalar is a regional interpretation of mole inspired by Bacalar and its unique blend of Maya, Caribbean, and Mexican influences. Mole itself comes from the Nahuatl word mōlli, meaning sauce, and refers to a family of deeply complex sauces made from chiles, seeds, spices, herbs, and sometimes cacao. While ancient Maya did not prepare Mole Bacalar specifically, many of its foundational ingredients were central to Mayan cuisine, including pumpkin seeds, chiles, tomatoes and cacao. This gives the dish strong indigenous roots. Mole Bacalar reflects Bacalar’s crossroads identity, blending indigenous traditions, colonial influences, and coastal flavors into a dish that beautifully captures the region’s culinary evolution.
Kanki Shrimp reflects contemporary coastal Mexican cooking, harking back to Coastal Maya communities' practice of harvesting seafood from the lagoons and mangroves of the Caribbean and paring them with indigenous ingredients such as boniato (a native sweet potato). As such, the dish represents the evolution of Yucatán cuisine into the modern era, where chefs blend local seafood with bold flavors like habanero, citrus, and tropical ingredients.
Cochinita Pibil is the defining dish of Yucatán cuisine. Pork is marinated in native achiote, sour orange, garlic, and spices, then wrapped in banana leaves and slow cooked until fall apart tender. Traditionally served with pickled red onions, habanero salsa, and corn tortillas, its flavor is earthy, citrusy, and deeply aromatic. The name tells its story: cochinita means “little pig,” while pibil comes from the Mayan word pib, an underground earth oven. This cooking method predates the Spanish by centuries and was used by the ancient Maya for ceremonial feasts. The twist is that pigs were introduced by the Spanish in the 1500s, making Cochinita Pibil a perfect fusion of worlds: ancient Mayan technique with European livestock. Its signature reddish hue comes from Achiote, a sacred Mayan ingredient once used for food, medicine, and ritual. Today, Cochinita Pibil remains Yucatán’s most iconic culinary ambassador.
Flan de Coco, or coconut flan, is a tropical variation of one of the Spanish speaking world’s most beloved desserts: flan, a silky baked custard topped with caramel. Flan’s origins trace back to the Roman Empire, where early egg custards were made with milk and honey. The dessert later evolved in Spain under Arab influence, which introduced sugar and refined confection techniques, before being brought to the Americas during colonization. Its ties to Yucatán are rooted in the region’s tropical and Caribbean influences, where coconut became a natural addition to colonial desserts.The dish represents the sweeter, more modern chapter of Yucatán cuisine, blending European technique with tropical flavor.
Carlota de Limon is one of Mexico’s most beloved no bake desserts, a chilled layered treat made with lime, sweetened condensed milk, cream or evaporated milk, and Marie biscuit cookies. As it chills, the cookies soften into a cake like texture, creating a dessert somewhere between key lime pie, cheesecake, and an icebox cake. It likely draws inspiration from European charlottes and became widespread in Mexico during the 20th century with the rise of canned dairy and home refrigeration. Its connection to Yucatán lies in flavor: the region’s cuisine deeply values bright acidity from lime and sour orange.