Road Trip
United Plates of America
Location
3 East Main Street
Bay Shore, NY 11706
Attendance
101 Guests
Connect with the restaurant
Event Recap
It was a subtle change asked by Phil Krumpter, proprietor of Bay Shore’s Roadtrip, in response to our first-draft of a menu: “Please change ‘smoked brisket sandwich’ to ‘smoked brisket slider’.” We happily obliged, the menu was rich in savory, multi-layered specialties anyway. I think there was a “portions will be tiny, but we’ll give ‘em more if they want it” thrown in there, too.
… then one member showed up early on night one with his own Tupperware. It was, to say the least, a harbinger.
DCS got their Joey Chestnut on in October, celebrating America's 250th by indulging our penchant for “more”. While we’re a group that, normally, travels the world by tasting the unique cuisine of its many regions, there is perhaps no more unique a dining experience on Long Island than one that celebrates the cuisine of our own regions.
What Roadtrip does, highlighting a different states’ cuisine, week in week out, with a plethora of specials and the highest quality, all-American ingredients, is a testament to the passion and next-level drive of the American spirit, certainly the spirit of Mr. Krumpter. Oh, we should have known “tiny portions” and “sliders” never had a chance in September.
It was an unprecedented event in DCS history; never before, by our count, has a restaurant succeeded in churning out individualized portions, half or even full-sized plates I might add, of that high quality food, at that scale, and had us out the door at a reasonable hour while doing it.
Clearly Roadtrip has the operating prowess to back up its nation-sized ambition. And boy could we taste it those two nights (and, judging by the amount of take-out containers, for several nights thereafter); Vermont maple bacon opened the festivities with a sweet-savory punch, 18hr house-smoked St. Louis Ribs (one? Nay! Try a half-rack) fell off the bone, a Bronx Pork Cutlet set-closer tasted even better reheated the next day…
Oh, and that slider? More like a full-on fastball of a smoky brisket, cheddar, onion and aioli menagerie that would become the much-lauded talk of the DCS text circuit. Served on a full-sized burger bun, of course.
Thank you again to Phil and the hard working chefs and staff at Roadtrip. Their passion shone through so clearly that it was almost easy to forget how gargantuan a task it was that they were pulling off so seamlessly. But, then again, considering their weekly menu-shifts from state to state and back again, it’s just in their nature. We hope they succeed in snagging Guy Fieri!
Dishing it with DCS
Vermont & Maple: Maple sugaring shaped Vermont’s seasonal rhythms, rural economy and culinary identity. The practice began with Indigenous peoples long before European settlement, while later Vermonters developed sugarhouses, community gatherings and an extensive tradition of cooking with maple sugar and syrup. Vermont was already publishing dedicated maple cookbooks by 1888, encouraging its use in everyday dishes. Bacon provides a natural salty and smoky contrast to maple’s sweetness, and the Vermont Maple Sugar Makers’ Association now promotes maple bacon as a regional preparation.
Hawaii & Pineapple: Pineapple may not be native to Hawaii, but it became one of the islands’ defining crops, both economically and geopolitically. Commercial cultivation expanded during the late nineteenth century, and James Dole established his Oahu plantation in 1900. Canning technology, aggressive marketing and plantation agriculture soon made Hawaii a global center of pineapple production. The industry reshaped communities across Oahu, Maui and Lanai while drawing Japanese, Filipino, Korean, Portuguese and other immigrant workers whose descendants profoundly influenced modern Hawaiian culture and food. Production peaked during the mid twentieth century before companies shifted much of their agriculture overseas. Pineapple remains a powerful symbol of Hawaii, though its history also reflects land appropriation, demanding plantation labor and corporate control.
Chesapeake Region & Shellfish: Shellfish have sustained Chesapeake communities since Indigenous times, eventually supporting major fisheries, waterfront towns and specialized working boats. Eastern oysters became especially important, while blue crab emerged as Maryland’s most recognizable food symbol. Littleneck clams are authentic to the saltier southern portions of the Bay, although they never achieved the same cultural prominence. Tomato based seafood soups also belong to Maryland tradition, particularly Maryland crab soup, which commonly combines crab, tomatoes, corn and seasonal vegetables.
Maryland & Crabcakes: Crab cakes are inseparable from Maryland’s Chesapeake identity (along with football? ) . Traditional versions emphasize blue crab meat with very little binder, allowing the large pieces of crab to remain recognizable. Blue crabs have long supported Maryland watermen, picking houses, restaurants and communal summer crab feasts, becoming both an economic resource and a symbol of state pride. Maryland officially designated the blue crab its state crustacean in 1989. Printed crab cake recipes appeared by the late nineteenth century, while the phrase “Baltimore crab cakes” helped establish the dish nationally during the early twentieth century.
Texas & Smoked Brisket: Brisket became a Texas barbecue icon because the state’s cattle economy made beef plentiful, while slow smoking transformed a tough, inexpensive cut into something tender and deeply flavorful. Modern Texas barbecue grew from several traditions, including German butcher shops, African American pit cooking, Mexican American foodways and the practices of ranching communities. In Central Texas meat markets, customers historically bought smoked beef by the pound, often served on butcher paper with bread, pickles and onions rather than elaborate sauces. Brisket eventually became the defining meat of this style and a symbol of Texas culinary pride.
Louisiana Bayou & Creole Cuisine: Louisiana seafood cuisine developed through centuries of exchange among Indigenous, African, French, Spanish, Caribbean and Acadian communities. Shrimp became deeply embedded in the cooking and economy of the Gulf Coast, appearing in gumbos, stews and countless Creole restaurant dishes. Later Sicilian immigration added another layer to New Orleans food culture, producing seafood and spaghetti houses that blended Italian pasta traditions with local shellfish, tomatoes and spices.
Salmon & The Pacific Northwest: Salmon has sustained Pacific Northwest communities since long before Washington became a state. For the indigenous Coast Salish peoples, it is not merely food but a foundation of ceremony, identity, trade and spiritual life. First Salmon ceremonies honor the returning fish and express responsibility for protecting future runs. Later commercial fisheries and canneries made salmon central to Washington’s economy, though dams, habitat loss and overfishing severely reduced many populations. Tribes now share responsibility for fisheries management and remain leaders in restoration. Deception Pass itself was an important fishing location, where salmon moving through its powerful tidal waters were captured in nets.
St. Louis & Ribs: St. Louis style ribs emerged from the city’s twentieth century meatpacking culture, when local butchers standardized pork spare ribs into a straighter, more presentable rack. The cut eventually became nationally recognized, even though it describes the shape of the ribs rather than one mandatory seasoning or cooking method. St. Louis barbecue traditionally favors pork, particularly ribs, rib tips, pork steaks and snoots, often paired with a sweet, tangy tomato sauce. The city’s barbecue culture was also profoundly shaped by Black cooks and restaurateurs whose families arrived from the American South. Today, some local pitmasters grill and sauce their ribs, while others slow smoke them using techniques borrowed from neighboring barbecue traditions.
Bronx & Italian-American Cuisine: Italian immigrants began settling around Belmont and Arthur Avenue in the late nineteenth century, and by the early 1900s the neighborhood had become an established Little Italy, filled with butchers, bakeries, markets and restaurants. Breaded cutlets descend from Italian traditions, while pairing them with tomato sauce, cheese and pasta reflects the richer, meat heavy cooking that evolved in Italian American communities.
America & Carrot Cake: Carrot cake has European roots, but the version Americans know today became a distinctly American classic. One of the earliest documented American appearances of the term “carrot cake” was in a 1912 Portland, Oregon community cookbook. Its real rise came decades later, especially in the 1960s and 1970s, when moist, spiced carrot cake paired with rich cream cheese frosting became a restaurant and home baking favorite. American versions often added walnuts, pecans, raisins, coconut or pineapple, turning a relatively humble vegetable cake into something rich and indulgent. That transformation is very American in spirit: practical roots, regional variation, and eventually oversized decadence. It may not have been invented here, but cream cheese frosted carrot cake earned a permanent place in the American dessert canon.